Wednesday, October 26, 2011

A Website to Nowhere

For close to a month ads have been running on KMOX. A man and a woman apparently sitting in a bar are concerned that people are smoking. After the man states that he thought there was a smoking ban, the woman explains that there are loopholes in the law. He states that it’s not fair or healthy. The narrator goes on to tell listeners to go to http://smokefreestl.org to find information on helping close the loopholes.

It’s a typical ad that is meant to drive users to the website. The ad is designed to appeal to listeners to take action. What I find baffling is if a listener actually went to the website they would find little information. The website as of 10/26/2011 has not been updated since July. Even then most recent updates have been links to newspaper articles. Anyone going to the site wouldn’t find any useable information.

The website is that of the nearly defunct Smoke-Free St Louis Organization. They were very active in 2009 helping to pass the St Louis City smoking ban. About two weeks before the Board of Alderman voted on the ban SFSTL lost its funding. I noted then that once nobody was paid to show at the aldermanic meeting all participation stopped. Over the next two years there have been only a couple of postings to the site.

When you look at the cost to write, pay voice actors and produce the ad how they could make such as simple mistake. Even worse, the ad ran many times daily for a month and no one ever thought to correct it. I can only guess to how much was spent on the campaign. It had to be tens of thousands if not hundreds of thousands. Can you imagine a private company spending its advertising budget to promote a product that didn’t exist!

I have mixed feelings on this latest use of stimulus funds. As someone who opposes smoking bans, I’m happy they are not using taxpayer money in an efficient way to reduce our freedom. As a taxpayer it really upsets me that I along with all Americans have to pay this money back.

Tony Palazzolo

Sunday, October 09, 2011

Secondhand Paint Smoke

Is it plausible that burning paint with a torch outside could cause this sort of catastrophic effect described by this mom? I am very sceptical:


Sunday, October 02, 2011

American Cancer Society Missouri Tobacco Tax Increase Proposal

American Cancer Society Tobacco Tax

By this initiative petition, the American Cancer Society seeks to ensure for itself a permanent source of Missouri taxpayer funding for it lobbying activities.

Thursday, September 22, 2011

Tobacco Free St. Louis Warning Letter

Dear Tobacco-Free St. Louis Directors and Officers,

All this year the singe focus of Tobacco Free St. Louis has been its escalating lobbying campaign meant to induce County municipalities to pass strict smoking bans, and to force the St. Louis County Council to eliminate all exemptions from St. Louis County's Indoor Clean Air Code. This lobbying campaign has culminated
in an attempt by Chairwoman Fraser, detailed this week in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, to enlist a federal agency to pressure the Council on this matter:
http://www.stltoday.com/news/local/metro/article_ababeaef-313f-51ff-85b5-433d14bacd63.html

Clearly a 501c3 educational charity such as Tobacco Free St. Louis is not allowed to devote itself to influencing legislation in this way: http://www.irs.gov/charities/article/0,,id=163392,00.html

While I do not wish to limit the speech or tactics of any group trying to influence St. Louis County government, it is wrong for any group lobbying to restrict the freedom of County businesses to enjoy the advantage of 501c3 tax-exempt status unavailable to the threatened businesses. I therefore ask that Tobacco Free St. Louis either abide by the lobbying rules governing 501c3 charities, or voluntarily give up its tax-exempt status. All I am asking for in this matter is fairness.

Sincerely,

Bill Hannegan

Home phone: 314.367.3779
Cell phone: 314.315.3779

Thursday, August 25, 2011

Lets Face It

Lets Face It is the slogan for the anti-tobacco campaign for St Louis County. It comes from the 7.6 million dollar stimulus grant to St Louis County. They have run commercials over the past several months. One commercial caught my attention. It wasn't that the message was new or unique. It was what the message included. The commercial is several young people making statements. One of the statements is "smoking makes you look cool". The message is that people say all kinds of weird things that aren't true. The statement that I found odd was "One day I'll find calculus useful." Now we have a government agency making fun of a higher education. Are we now using tax dollars to dissuade people from higher learning? Now I don't believe that anyone is going to drop calculus because of this commercial. Of course I don't believe that anyone is going to quit smoking either. One idea did pop in my mind. Of course they don't like people with higher math skills. The entire anti-smoking campaign is built on the general populations lack of math skill. If you understand how to read the research you understand that the "risk" is so small that it can't be measured. You would understand that driving to a restaurant or bar is hundreds of times more risky. You would ask questions that they can't answer honestly. I'm sure this was not their intent. I don't have a problem with programs that help people stop smoking. Does it really take millions of dollars to advertise a website that regurgitated all the quit smoking strategies. Even worse it pushes people away from far more effective methods of auricular therapy, electronic cigarettes and cold turkey. The message is that the only way to do it is with pharma nicotine replacement drugs and counseling. Its really a taxpayer paid advertisement for pharmaceutical solutions. I wouldn't have a problem if it was effective. I wouldn't have a problem if it disseminated unbiased information. I wouldn't have a problem if as a taxpayer I didn't have to pay this money back. Lets Face It, they are more interested in pushing pharma products then helping people quit. Lets face it, it's a complete waste of money.


Tony Palazzolo

Wednesday, August 03, 2011

Councilman Steve Stenger

Back in March, Tobacco Free St. Louis head Pat Lindsey assured everyone that the elimination of exemptions was such "a done deal" by County Executive Dooley and the Health Department that she didn't even need to lobby anymore, as if an exemption free ordinance had already been written.
http://blogs.riverfronttimes.com/dailyrft/2011/03/county_smoking_ban_exemptions_st_louis.php

New Tobacco Free St. Louis head Barb Fraser recently warned the County Council that they owed the elimination of the exemptions in exchange for the $7,000,000 of Stimulus money the County Health Department got to fight smoking.
http://mogasp.wordpress.com/2011/08/01/2011-07-27-p-d-st-louis-county-council-is-urged-to-end-smoking-ban-exemptions/

I am glad to see that Councilman Stenger has resolved to do his own independent thinking on this issue. Check Jason Rosenbaum's Patch article on Stenger:

http://clayton-richmondheights.patch.com/articles/stenger-smoking-ban-changes-wont-come-immediately


Sunday, July 17, 2011

Barbara Fraser and Tobacco Free St. Louis

Dear Board Members of Tobacco Free St. Louis,

An article by Brett Blume of KMOX identifies Barbara Fraser as the new head of Tobacco Free St. Louis. If this is so, I hope the Board will remind Ms. Fraser that her new position puts limits on her former ability to lobby for smoking bans. I am all for Ms. Fraser's freedom to promote specific smoking ban legislation as a private citizen or councilman, but she now can no longer do that as the head of a tax-exempt educational charity. Her statements at the July 13th press conference clearly constitute the "lobbying" or "attempts to influence legislation" in St. Louis County that is beyond the legitimate educational purpose of a 501c3 charity.
http://www.irs.gov/charities/article/0,,id=163392,00.html

I hope in the future Ms.Fraser will work to educate the St. Louis public concerning the dangers of tobacco smoke and the possible benefits of smoking bans in general, but leave the fight for specific new laws for St. Louis County to grassroots political groups who can legitimately undertake that fight.

Sincerely,

Bill Hannegan
Home phone: 314.367.3779
Cell phone: 314.315.3779